Recognising International Commercial Surrogacy Could Be "Difficult To Justify"

Friday, 28 January 2022 09:52

By Caoimhe Harney

A new bill is before the Oireachtas.

Recognising international commercial surrogacy arrangements, where women in foreign countries receive payment to have babies for Irish parents, could be “difficult to justify”, according to an options paper drawn up by officials for a special Oireachtas committee.

Despite this, Irish couples travelling to Ukraine to have their babies via surrogacy are expected to receive special diplomatic assistance, as tension increases between the country and Russia.

So far, 14 families that are planning to have babies in Ukraine have contacted Fine Gael Senator Mary Seery-Kearney.

Any parents in the country currently or are planning to travel there soon are asked to register with the Department of Foreign Affairs.

Senator Seery-Kearney has said contingency plans are in place if the violence breaks out in Ukraine.

Currently there are no laws governing surrogacy in Ireland.

The committee is to be set up to make recommendations on how the law should treat international surrogacy in a new Bill that is currently before the Oireachtas.

But an options paper to be given to the new committee warns about the dangers of recognising or facilitating international commercial surrogacy arrangements.

Dr. Conor O' Mahony commented: "We have laws governing donor assisted reproduction.

"When it comes to a woman giving birth to a child but is not raising the child, there are all sorts of issues.

"The most popular place that Irish people go for surrogacy is Ukraine and California.

"The woman who carries the child is compensated," he said.

"There are all sorts of ethical and legal issues that arise," he added

He told Clem Ryan on this morning's Kildare Today that Mothers with children born through surrogacy are often left in limbo in Ireland.

Special Rapporteur on Child Protection & Senior Lecturer, School of Law, UCC, Dr. Conor O'Mahony :

More from Local News

Call For Sanitary Bins In Men’s Toilets To Support Prostate Cancer Survivors

Audio

Each year, around 4000 men in Ireland are diagnosed with the disease, with research from PHS and the Irish Cancer Society finding more than half of men with incontinence feel anxious because of poor toilet facilities.
Own-Brand Foods Often Produced By Same Factories As Big Labels, Says Money Doctor John Lowe

Choosing own-brand products can also save money, with Lowe noting that many supermarket labels are produced by the same manufacturers as well-known brands.
Kfm Strengthens Position As Kildare’s Most Listened-To Station, According To Latest Ipsos/MRBI Report

Kfm CEO Clem Ryan said: “This latest research is a major reflection of the power of local radio, which showcases local issues , and where advertisers reach their target customers in real time."
Quarter Of Uisce Éireann Staff Earned Over €100k Last Year

Audio

Officials from Uisce Eireann are appearing before the Public Accounts Committee, outlining the company’s financial statements for 2024.
Meath Bird Flu Case Prompts Warning, But Chicken And Turkey Safe To Eat, Says Agriculture Minister

Audio

After confirmed cases in Carlow and Cork, the Department of Agriculture is imposing a mandatory order for all poultry and captive birds to be kept indoors from next Monday.
One-Month Road Closure In Catherinestown To Start Next Week To Facilitate Maynooth Pipeline Works

The road will shut from the junction with the L5050 at Catherinstown to the L1015 at Kellystown from November 10th to December 6th.
Commuter Chaos On M7/N7 Renews Calls For Standby Emergency Response Team During Morning Gridlock

Minister for Public Expenditure and Infrastructure Jack Chambers said he would ask Transport Infrastructure Ireland (TII) and the Minister Of Transport to better resource the response to certain incidents.
Thousands Of Workers Could Get Tax Back In Time For Christmas, Says Financial Advisor

People can also claim on GP visits, prescriptions and rent - along with flat rate expenses for certain professions.